First Circuit -- Sony BMG Music Entertainment v. Tenenbaum

Napster sharing verdict largely upheld, remand on damages.

Statutory damages under the Copyright Act survive Feltner 7th Amendment challenge.

Act's prohibitions encompass consumer copiers.

Proof of harm not required for award of statutory damages.

No error in jury instructions setting forth range of statutory damages.

Infringement is willful if it is knowing.

Error to the District Court for considering whether damages offended due process before considering remittitur.

Sony BMG Music Entertainment v. Tenenbaum